The Witch Farm Episode 1 REVIEW

The Witch Farm, the long-awaited TV adaptation of Danny Robins’ popular podcast, gets off to a superb start with an atmospheric first episode full of creeping tension and unsettling silences, writes GEMMA JOHNSON

The Witch Farm, the long-awaited TV adaptation of Danny Robins’ popular podcast, gets off to a superb start with an atmospheric first episode full of creeping tension and unsettling silences, writes GEMMA JOHNSON

Gemma Johnson

By

Gemma Johnson

22 November 2026 · 5 min read

Publicity image from The Witch Farm, BBC television series.

Those who know me know that I am not typically a fan of Danny Robins and the whole Uncanny movement – controversial, I know. It is nothing personal against Danny, Uncanny just hasn’t been my vibe. (I can hear your gasps from here).

Why then am I the reviewer for the new Witch Farm series, you may ask? I enjoyed Danny’s work before Uncanny came along, when it was more of him in his spooky garden shed kind of vibe. Witch Farm and The Battersea Poltergeist were his best work, in my opinion, and so when our Spooky Isles Editor invited me to review this new series, I gladly accepted.

Before the hate mail arrives, know that I am not anti-Danny Robins, I just prefer his early work. So here I am, Sunday afternoon on my sofa, surrounded by my dogs and hot cup of tea in hand. Let’s go.

A house with an ominous welcome

Our first taste of Heol Fanog is a wide shot of an isolated house in the rolling Brecon Beacons, crows looming and cawing in the background and a concerned priest making his way into the house. It is 1969 and something bad is brewing.

The house wouldn’t be out of place in a horror film, the location scout for this series is worth their weight in gold. We follow the priest into the house and find that the interior is equally as eerie.

Have you ever been to Newsham Park in Liverpool? If you have then I bet that when you saw the upstairs it made you think of the long looming “Naughty Boys Corridor”. A space where you feel slightly on edge, doors to spaces that are ominous and a sense of being watched.

And with that, we see the priest lured into a room and the door slam. Welcome to Witch Farm.

Michael Socha as Bill alongside Gabrielle Creevy as Liz in The Witch Farm.
Michael Socha as Bill and Gabrielle Creevy as Liz in The Witch Farm. Image: BBC.

Silence at Heol Fanog

20 years later, we see Bill, Liz and Jonno making their way to Heol Fanog for a fresh start. Although I have just seen a priest being locked in a room by an unseen presence, I have to admit that I would still seriously consider living in that house.

It is isolated, surrounded by beautiful Welsh countryside and in the words of Bill, “Somewhere that’s not all concrete and dog s**t, in your own bubble.” He also declares that he hates people and I immediately connect with him. But being transparent, I was bound to because Bill is played by Michael Socha who is a very talented actor.

Young Jonno comments on the house feeling weird because of the quiet, one of the things that I respected most about how this has been filmed is that there is a palpable sense of heavy silence and it looms in the background throughout.

There is a gentle arc of impending doom being created and it was delightful. An example is when Liz is telling Bill about the Welsh folklore relating to Gwrach y Rhibyn during a thunderstorm. A Welsh evil hag with black eyes and teeth and leathery wings that knock on doors.

I confess that I do indeed live in a haunted house and we are frequently subject to the sound of heavy footsteps walking around upstairs when there is no-one there; so I was able to relate to the scene of Liz going to the bathroom and hearing them around her. It is bizarre and unnerving, and no, we don’t have clog-wearing mice in our house.

Gabrielle Creevy as Liz in the BBC television series The Witch Farm.
Gabrielle Creevy as Liz in The Witch Farm. Image: BBC.

Nostalgia and creeping fear

The family settles into the house, there is a new baby, a new art studio, a wedding and lots of decorating. Shout out to my homegirl Lisa Stansfield, also from and still living in Rochdale, who was playing in the background of a decorating scene.

Although I know what is going to unfold within the house, I couldn’t help but feel a sense of comfort with it being set in the late 1980s/early 1990s. I almost squealed when I saw cheese and pineapple on a stick at the wedding buffet. Yes, I know there is a tragic ending looming further down the line, but grant me a moment of nostalgia.

Tension slowly starts to build through subtleties – grumpy neighbour Wyn Jones giving coded warnings, brief movements in an upstairs window, shared vivid dreams, the discovery of ruins nearby featuring mysterious witch marks and a scared plumber.

There are no jump scares here, instead a gradual layering of fear which was delightful. The crows are excellently used as an indicator that something is coming, appearing or cawing in the background.

When there is a big event, a sense of chaos is created as a jolting contrast to the heavy silence. A well-filmed example was Liz with baby Ben, a build-up of a crying baby, a loud horror film which gets louder, something falling off a shelf, a door slamming and Liz screaming.

The location, the cast, the filming and screenwriting have all created a superb first episode of Witch Farm. But I leave you with one question – if your partner told you they had seen a ghost, would you believe them?

The Witch Farm is now available on BBC iPlayer, with new episodes airing on BBC One at 9pm on Sundays and Mondays until 30 November 2026.

Safe, educational paranormal adventures for young people

For young people aged nine to 17, Junior Paranormal Events combines historical discovery, hands-on investigation and critical thinking with a strong commitment to child safety. Co-founded by qualified teacher and Spooky Isles writer Gemma Johnson, its events are led by experienced educators, with safeguarding procedures, risk-assessed venues and age-appropriate activities.

Explore Junior Paranormal Events →

Join the conversation in the Spooky Isles Facebook Group →

Author

Gemma Johnson

Explore more: · ·

Spooky Isles 15th Anniversary Pin Badge Spooky Isles 15th Anniversary BadgeKeep Halloween alive 365 days a year£7.99 delivered in the UKBuy the badge →