REVIEW: Whistle and I’ll Come To You

REVIEW: Whistle and I’ll Come To You

Whistle and I'll Come To You

ADAM SCOVELL reviews BBC Ghost Stories: Whistle and I’ll Come to You due to be released this week by the BFI

The first of the two BFI releases due out on the 20th of August,  the first double bill of the classic BBC ghost story adaptations sets the tone for the future releases while also justifying the detail and time put into them.  This release contains both adaptations of perhaps M.R James’ most famous short tale and the release plays wonderfully on the natural juxtaposition of the two very different interpretations.

The 1968 version adapted by the talented Jonathan Miller (The Drinking Party, Alice in Wonderland) kick starts this series with chilling perspicacity.  Sir Michael Hordern plays an academic professor on holiday on the Norfolk coast.  The adaptation focuses on belief systems and how the professor’s pompous logic becomes the undoing of him as he becomes increasingly more haunted after finding an old whistle in a graveyard by the sea.  Though the presence of Horden brings to mind images of a certain travelling bear, his performance is astonishingly detailed and nuanced playing an atypical academic with crumbling people skills and mind alike.

This is a piece of work that revels in both its visuals and its soundscape.  Miller focuses on the eerie landscape, making it seem beautiful but haunting at the same time.  The idea of a possessed object or an “inorganic demon” as the wonderful accompanying booklet describes it as, is a powerful one, yet here it’s possible to read the haunting as attacks of self doubt or even dementia as well.  The actual visuals of the ghosts are subtlety unnerving but the real scares come from the sounds of film.  The dreamscape of Parkin as he’s chased along the beach and then sees a cloth-like entity is only truly scary due to the horrible delayed effects of his own voice and waking.  The same goes for the final haunting where the sounds of rustling sheets and Parkins own hysteria are terrifying and a real jolt as the adaptation ends.

Andy de Emmony’s 2010 adaptation is a very different beast.  It seems unfairly maligned for being flexible with the source material as well different to the 1968 version, yet it seems that this is only born out of adoration for the originals rather than any real genuine criticism of the adaptation.  John Hurt plays our professor sceptic this time, yet he is on no mere holiday.  The version opens with Parkin putting his wife into a home as she’s shut down completely with dementia.  This is far more dark territory than previously explored but it also adds to the emotional impact of the haunting, making it sad as well as scary.

The crux of this adaptation is being haunted by someone who is potentially still alive, at least in the physical sense.  Parkin is almost angry at the hotel receptionist’s blasé approach to ghosts, where he’s positive that the we are physical and we rot, both inside and out.  This implies further that he is in fact being haunted by his wife’s spirit having left her living body though a shock twist of an ending leaves it wonderfully ambiguous.

Apart from coming with the aforementioned booklet, the release comes with a small collection of extras as well a brilliant restoration job on the 1968 adaptation.  Along with a slightly rambling introduction to the Miller adaptation by Ramsey Cambell, he reads his own James inspired Ghost story: The Guide.  There’s also an eerie reading of the original James short by Neil Brand and a short discussion with Jonathan Miller and Christopher Frayling about the program.

Ghosts are scarier in fiction when they strike fear into the hearts of non-believers.  Both versions of Whistle and I’ll Come To You play on this admirably and are the defining release of this range.  A frighteningly brilliant start that is rich in British gothic sensibilities, innovation and taste.

ADAM SCOVELL is a music student specialising in film music.  When not obsessively watching and writing about film, he can be found playing jazz in seedy clubs and making short films found at

Click to add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Adam Scovell is a writer and filmmaker currently studying for a PhD in Music at the University of Liverpool. He has written for The Times and The Guardian, had films screened at Manchester Art Gallery, FACT and The Everyman Playhouse, and runs the twice Blog North Awards nominated website, Celluloid Wicker Man.

More in Television

Farewell Douglas Wilmer – TV’s Sherlock Holmes

Michael S. Collins3rd April 2016

Is Rupert Everett the most underrated Sherlock Holmes?

Jon Rees23rd March 2016

The many faces of Sherlock’s ‘the woman’ Irene Adler

Nia Jones22nd March 2016

Elementary Englishman in New York with Sherlock Stateside

Ann O'Regan21st March 2016

Houdini and Doyle: It’s Balderdash, Holmes – And Quite a Blast!

Matt Wingett14th March 2016

Remembering Channel 4’s Monster Horrors Season (1986)

Richard Phillips-Jones9th January 2016

Why TV’s Sherlock has lost the plot

Matt Wingett3rd January 2016

Most Haunted: Queen Mary Part Two REVIEW

MJ Steel Collins16th October 2015

Most Haunted: Queen Mary Part One REVIEW

MJ Steel Collins11th October 2015

Childermass is a Yorkshire Jedi: Enzo Cilenti interview

Andrew Garvey6th July 2015

Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell Ep 7: Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell REVIEW

Andrew Garvey1st July 2015

Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell Ep 6: The Black Tower REVIEW

Andrew Garvey29th June 2015