REVIEW: The Wicker Tree (2011)

REVIEW: The Wicker Tree (2011)
Andrew Garvey

TITLE: The Wicker Tree

DIRECTOR: Robin Hardy
CAST: Brittania Nicol, Henry Garrett and Graham McTavish


Buy The Wicker Tree on DVDWritten, directed and adapted from his own book Cowboys For Christ, octogenarian Robin Hardy’s the Wicker Tree is a follow-up / companion piece to his own 1973 masterpiece of British horror, the Wicker Man.

And sadly, it’s awful.

The film opens with two young Texan missionaries, Steve and Beth, preparing to set off and preach God’s word to the people of Scotland who, according to their creepily enthusiastic pastor, “don’t even believe in angels.”

On arrival they are befriended by bald-headed, goatee-bearded (he may as well have ‘villain’ tattooed across his face) nobleman Sir Lachlan Morrison and his wife, Delia.

Not quite the one-dimensional God botherers they first appear to be, cowboy-hatted ex-gambler Steve is having some serious trouble remembering why he wears a silver purity ring and Beth is ashamed of her past as a raunchy country singer.

Finding countless Glaswegian doors slammed in their cheery, leafleting faces, Beth and Steve accept the Morrisons’ invitation to the lowlands village of Tressock, where they encounter some oddball locals with a taste for pagan folk music, a raven-owning simpleton and Lolly, an inferior photocopy of the character played by Britt Ekland in the Wicker Man.

With Beth’s simple-minded belief in things she assumes are written in the Bible and Steve’s use of his cowboy hat as a security blanket, the pair of them are laughably unconvincing as preachers but the locals enthusiastically choose a delighted Beth as the May Queen in their annual festival and a perpetually confused-looking Steve as her Laddie, an honour they will soon be regretting, despite the hints so heavily dropped by the locals, one of whom repeatedly calls them ‘lambs’.

Mostly shot in London and various locations in Scotland, fans of the Wicker Man will spot plenty of nods and references, enough that it actually becomes a welcome distraction from the slowly unfolding story.

Even Christopher Lee pops up in a twaddle-spouting flashback scene.

But the Wicker Tree completely lacks the original’s nagging sense of dread and unease and, aside from the script and some of the acting, nothing even vaguely horrifying happens until well over an hour has passed.

The jaunty soundtrack makes much of the film’s plodding ninety-six minutes about as threatening as an afternoon watching CBeebies and some of the performances (particularly the wild-eyed pantomiming of Morrison’s henchman Beame) come across as cack-handed parody.

Despite some creepy ideas, largely those rehashed from the original and then hopelessly bungled, the film is a complete mess and definitely one to avoid.

ANDREW GARVEY lives in Staffordshire.  He writes (infrequently) about mixed martial arts, professional wrestling, history, horror and folklore.  Follow him on Twitter: @AMGarvey Check out more Andrew Garvey articles for the Spooky Isles here.

View Comments (2)


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Andrew Garvey

ANDREW GARVEY is Spooky Isles' Associate Editor. He lives in Staffordshire. He writes (infrequently) about mixed martial arts, professional wrestling, history, horror and folklore.

More in Films

The Unkindness of Ravens

The Unkindness Of Ravens

MJ Steel Collins30th November 2015
Pride and Predjudice and Zombies

New trailer for Pride and Prejudice and Zombies! VIDEO

David Saunderson26th November 2015

Crimson Peak (2015) REVIEW

Ann O'Regan9th November 2015

An Evening with Boris Karloff and His Friends (1967) AUDIO

Richard Phillips-Jones25th October 2015
Harry Potter and Half Blood Prince Film Poster

Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince (2009) REVIEW

Sarah Blair-Dickinson20th October 2015

Uncovering 1970s Horror Memories

David Saunderson17th October 2015

One Way, coming this way in 2016

Richard Phillips-Jones16th October 2015

The Phantom Of The Opera (1989) REVIEW

Richard Phillips-Jones15th October 2015
The Redwood Massacre

The Redwood Massacre (2014) REVIEW

Andrew Garvey10th October 2015

The Fall Of The House Of Usher (1949) REVIEW

Richard Phillips-Jones7th October 2015

Corruption (1967) REVIEW

Richard Phillips-Jones1st October 2015

Fallen Soldiers (2015) REVIEW

Simon Ball16th September 2015